Posted by Lisa on April 14, 2010
By Christopher Leonard (AP)
KANSAS CITY, Mo. — Federal regulators are set to release the most sweeping antitrust rules covering the meat industry in decades, potentially altering the balance of power between meat companies and the farmers who raise their animals.
Activists, farmers and meat industry officials have been anxiously awaiting the new rules, which will be released this spring for public comment and are set to take effect this summer. The regulations are seen as a kind of litmus test for the Obama administration and how far it will go in regulating competition in the meat industry.
At issue is how much power farmers have as they produce cattle, hogs and chickens for large companies such as JBS SA, Smithfield Farms and Tyson Foods. The new rules will govern how meatpackers buy their cattle on an open market and what demands poultry companies can make on the independent contractors who raise their chickens.
"We have high hopes for them," said Mike Weaver, a West Virginia poultry farmer who raises chickens under contract for Pilgrim's Pride. "We've been promised that there will be sweeping changes in these new rules, but nobody's seen them."
The 2008 Farm Bill required updated rules but left the specifics to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Farm state lawmakers such as Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, had long been concerned a lack of competition among meat companies was driving down prices farmers were paid for their cattle and poultry.
Just four companies buy and slaughter 80 percent of all U.S. beef, limiting competition in the meat industry. Meanwhile, big poultry companies dictate chicken prices and can demand farmers take on debt to upgrade their chicken houses for the companies' benefit.
Farmers such as Weaver, who has met with Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack, think the new leaders in the USDA's antitrust division will push for tougher and more far-reaching regulations than previous administrations. Some believe the new rules could be the strongest antitrust protections imposed since the Great Depression.
There's also a risk they will drive up the cost of meat, eating into meatpackers' profits or pushing up prices at grocery stores if companies pass on the expense.
The USDA wouldn't say when its proposed rules will be released, but the Farm Bill requires new regulations be in place by this summer. The bill lays out a broad outline of what the rules must address, but the all-important details won't be known until a proposal becomes public.
The regulations come at a time when the Obama administration has begun a series of meetings across the country to examine competition in agriculture. Officials with the Agriculture and Justice Departments, who are conducting the hearings, have said they don't know what kind of action could result, but it's clear the meat industry is under more scrutiny than it has been for years.
Among issues expected to be addressed in the new rules is when it's illegal for companies to choose one producer's cattle or hogs over another's.
Ranchers have complained that meatpackers make their choices with an aim toward keeping prices low. For example, meatpackers might pass by independent ranchers to buy cattle raised under contracts that guarantee processors a lower price.
Iowa hog farmer Chuck Wirtz is torn about the rules. He sells most of his hogs on the open market and feels squeezed by big meatpackers. At the same time, he wouldn't want the rules to restrict the market too much.
"I personally probably get preferential treatment, because I'm rather large," he said, noting that meatpackers will pay him more for hogs if he can deliver several hundred at a time.
Wirtz is worried the new rule could say such a deal is illegal if another farmer is passed over.
Such details have been worked over for months within the obscure USDA agency that regulates competition in the meat industry, called the Packers and Stockyards Administration. The PSA was formed in 1921 to limit the power of big meatpackers that dominated the industry.
Ranchers have long criticized the agency as toothless. A 2006 government report said the agency was slow to bring cases and understaffed. But some hope it will be tougher under the direction of its new administrator, Dudley Butler, a lawyer who specialized in suing poultry companies.
Butler declined to comment on the rules.
The new rules also would determine when poultry companies could require farmers to take out additional loans and improve chicken houses by adding new equipment. Farmers resist the investments because although they might earn more money after the upgrades, the extra income doesn't offset the extra debt and cost of operating the houses.
"Eighty percent or more of the upgrade benefits the company and not the grower. And the growers are the ones who pay for it. And that's unfair, plain and simple unfair," Weaver said.
Richard Lobb, a spokesman for the National Chicken Council, said farmers and poultry companies share the benefit when farmers upgrade a house. Birds grow faster, which can allow more flocks a year to be grown on a farm, he said.
Companies such as Tyson Foods, which produces beef, chicken and pork, will be ready to challenge rules they consider too strict.
"We're already in one of the most heavily regulated industries in the nation and take compliance with the law very seriously," Tyson spokesman Gary Mickelson said in an e-mail. "However, we don't believe additional rules are needed to control the relationship between livestock and poultry producers and food companies like ours."
Copyright © 2010 The Associated Press.
LATEST LINKS
CATEGORIES
- Animal Welfare
- Antitrust and Monopoly
- Bees/Colony Collapse
- Biotech
- Child Nutrition
- Climate Change
- Corn
- Corporate America
- Dr. Don Huber
- Factory Farms
- Family Farmers
- Farm Bill
- Food and Ag Policy
- Food Safety
- Food Safety
- Genetic engineering (GMOs)
- Global food supply
- Health and Obesity
- Industrial Meat
- Iowa
- Labeling
- Local Food
- Monsanto
- Monsanto Background
- Monsanto Latest
- Occupy Wall Street
- Organics
- OSGATA et al vs. Monsanto
- Pesticides
- Pink Slime
- Rural America
- Seeds
- Subsidies
- Sustainable Agriculture
BLOG ROLL
- Culinate
- Institute for Rural Journalism
- La Vida Locavore
- Lettuce Eat Kale
- Locavores
- Marler Blog
- Obamafoodorama
- Politics of the Plate
- Retrovore
- The Jew and the Carrot
- The People Who Feed Us
- The Slow Cook
- US Food Policy blog
- Hush Supper Club
- Grist
- Daily Yonder
- DTN Ag Policy Blog
- Eating Liberally
- Eat Local Challenge
- Edible Communities
- Ethicurean
- Farm Policy News
- Food Politics
- Food Renegade
- Food Safety News
- Food Sleuth Radio
- Garden of Eating blog
- Green Fork
- Yale Sustainable Food Project
ARCHIVES
Tell Vilsack No Pink Slime in School Lunches – Ever again!
Farmers Determined to Defend Right to Grow Food File Appeal in OSGATA vs. Monsanto
Tell Congress: I Want an Organic Farm Bill
Video: I Stand with Farmers vs. Monsanto
Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto, Hundreds Converge in Support
Organic farmers’ suit against Monsanto’s genetically modified seeds
Farmers advance in their suit against Monsanto
Modified Crops Tap a Wellspring of Protest
Photos from A Citizen's Assembly: OSGATA et al vs Monsanto J31
Hinesburg farmers join lawsuit challenging Monsanto by Sally Pollack
Family Farmers Get Their Day In Court Against Monsanto
A Citizen's Assembly of Support for Family Farmers vs. Monsanto
Occupy Iowa Caucus: A Democrat "Uncommitted" in 2012 or Why I Won’t Caucus for Obama a Second Time
Judge to consider oral arguments in lawsuit against Monsanto
Happy Holidays: Farmers March on Wall Street
Farmers March with Occupy Wall Street: Sowing the Seeds of Hope and Democracy
Urban-Rural Solidarity: Farmers March on Wall Street
48 Hours to Stop Obama's New Tax on Family Farms
Immediate Release: Family Farmers Join Occupy Wall Street Farmers March in Solidarity
Speakers Update: Today Occupy Wall Street Farmers March - Sunday Dec 4th
Super Committee Fails, Secret Farm Bill Dies Ahead of Thanksgiving
Corrupt Bargain Reached on Secret Farm Bill: Details to Be Announced
Breaking: Secret Farm Bill Deal About to be Made
Four years ago today Obama and GMOs
Last Chance to Kill the Secret Farm Bill
24 Hours to Kill the "Secret Farm Bill"
Occupy Against Big Food tomorrow Zuccotti Park: 1 to 4 pm
Enough Tricks: Consumers Speak Up Against Monsanto’s GMO Sweet Corn
If You Eat, You Better Occupy Wall Street - Join World Food Day
New Rules Will Support Farmers and Jobs
Breaking Video: 2007 Campaign Promise, Obama Says He'll Label GMOs If Elected
Join the Right2Know March to Label GMOs: 313 Mile Walk from New York City to the White House
Taxpayer Subsidies Prop Up Junk Food Industry with Billions
Monsanto’s GM Sweet Corn Coming to America’s Dinner Plates
If You Eat, You Better Get GIPSA
Action: If You Eat, You Better Get GIPSA
Veteran Filmmaker Jan Weber Continues Her Documentary Travels
Tell Us How You Think Obama's Doing!
Politics, Farmers and Change: The End of Rural America
Farmers Defend Right to Protect Themselves From Monsanto Patents
24 Hours to Stop Monsanto's Erratic Genes
Join Us For The Iowa Premiere of the Groundbreaking Documentary - American Meat
Save a Farmer Today, Tell Obama to Create Fair Contracts for Family Farmers
Farmers must boost sustainable crops to feed the world
Public kept in the dark on Roundup link with birth defects
Ag Gag 2011: What Does Agribusiness Have to Hide in Iowa?
Why Did Tom Vilsack Ignore This Warning?
Will the USDA Toss the Sustainable Ag Movement A Perennial Bone?
"More Details on the Strange Organism That Could Destroy Monsanto"
Monsanto, Biotech Industry Allowed to Conduct Their Own GMO Assessments
Will the U.S. hog industry ever kick its reliance on low-dose antibiotics?
Dr. Don Huber's cover letter to the EU and UK commissions
Farmers and Consumer Groups File Lawsuit Challenging GMO Alfalfa Approval
Iowa Farmer and Sustainable Hero, Denise O'Brien Joins Obama Administration, Heads to Afghanistan
Save a farmer today - Help level the playing field - Call Congress Today
Update: Obama Goes Rogue on GMOs - Tell him to say NO to Monsanto: Part 3
Nature Happens - Humans Can't Control Everything, Particularly GE Alfalfa
Organic Dairy Farmer Albert Straus Speaks Out Against USDA’s Decision on GMO Alfalfa
Making Hay is as Messy as Making Sausages: Deregulating GE Alfalfa
EcoFarm Attendees Criticize USDA Decision to Allow GMO Alfalfa
Monsanto's Members of Congress Send Pro-GMO Letter to Secretary Vilsack
Act Now or Kiss your Organics good-bye!
Leopold Center offers plan to boost local food economy in Iowa
Colony Collapse or Killing Bees for Fun and Profit
Violins anyone? "Policy shift concerns biotech companies"
Top 5 food policy gains in 2010 (and what’s lagging behind)
The Rise of Agriculture: Orgies or Beer? You Only Get One
Update: Food Safety Bill Passes from Senate Back to House, Awaits President's Signature
Marler Says: Food Safety Bill May Soon Dine with the Fishes
Different Ideas about “Quality of Life”, Insights from Final DOJ/USDA Anti-Competition Hearing
Senate May Clear Path for Food Safety This Week
Your Voices Were Heard Loud and Clear in DC this Week, Thanks for Standing Up for Family Farmers
Activists Submit 240,000 Comments Demanding Action to Curb Food Monopolies
S.510 Clears Key Vote, Debate to Resume Today
Urgent VOTE TODAY: Final Food Safety Bill Vote Tonight - Call Now!
Mayhem on the Hill, Big Ag Declares War on Food Safety Bill
Politics, Small Farm Deal Stall Food Safety Bill
Food Safety Bill Clears Cloture: 74-25 Vote
Urgent Vote: Michael Pollan supports farmers: Do your Senators?
Critical Food Safety Vote on Nov. 17th - Call Your Senator Now!
New USDA Report: "Household Food Security in the U.S. 2009
Bombshell Revelation: FDA coverup on GMO Salmon - Act Today!
Iowa Governor 2010: Who Will Be the Worst Environmental Governor of the 21st Century?
First Lady Michelle Obama's White House Garden Continues to Inspire People Around the Globe!
Sustainability: How will agribusiness marketing redefine the term?
A New Agriculture Comes Alive in the Big Apple
Salmonella Egg King Jack DeCoster to Testify in Congress
Why are healthy food advocates stumping for Pepsi?
The Creepy Science Behind GMO "Frankenfish"
Act Today: Tell the FDA you won’t eat GMO salmon
Half A Billion Eggs, DeCoster, Factory Farms & Consolidation: The View From Iowa
Trader Joe’s, Fareway Stores Inc., Agree to Pull DeCoster-affiliated Egg Brands from their Shelves
Is your grocery store harboring "bad eggs"? It's time to fight back!
Salmonella Egg Recall Michael Pollan on CNN with Sanjay Gupta: Food Safety and Local Foods
Federal Court Rescinds USDA Approval of Genetically Engineered Sugar Beets
McDonald's: Jumping on the Locavore Bandwagon
Pesticide Lobby Launches Three-Year Campaign Against Organics
Monsanto Agrees to $2.5 million Fine for Sale of GMO Cotton Seeds
VIDEO: Cooking up a Story Takes on Monsanto Spin in Supreme Court GMO Alfalfa Case
DOJ Announces Agenda for Dairy Hearing in Madison, WI June 25th
Haiti aid must help Haitian farmers, not Big Ag
DOJ / USDA Hearing in Alabama on Poultry - News Wrapup
ADHD in Kids Tied to Organophosphate Pesticides
Department of Justice and USDA Announce Schedule and Panelists for Agriculture Workshop in Alabama
Supreme Court Nominee Elena Kagan Goes to Bat for Monsanto, Sides With Conservative Justices
Obama State Department Official Pledges to Confront Global Biotech / GMO Critics
Poultry Industry Gets New Performance Standards
Feds Investigate Major Meatpackers as Obama Administration Looks for Tougher Antitrust Action
Vilsack: Rural America Faces a 'Silent Crisis'
USDA Announces Upcoming Purchases of Commodities For Federal Food and Nutrition Assistance Programs
Senators Challenge "Know Your Farmer" Program
Supreme Court Hears Arguments on Genetically Modified Seeds
Agriculture Secretary Vilsack Makes Case for Stronger Rural America
Supreme Court Questions Ban of Biotech alfalfa
Ten Good Reasons Why GMOs Are Not Compatible With Organic Agriculture
Food Inc. Airs on PBS for Earth Day - April 21 thru May 3
140 Groups & Scientists Urge Senate to Oppose GM Clause in Global Food Security Act
Meat, Poultry Industries Await New Antitrust Rules
Senate Gears Up for Action on Food Safety
Response to Professor Mitloehner
Judge Denies Dean Foods' Motion to Dismiss Antitrust Case
Unsupported Claims About Livestock and Climate Change in the Media
Oklahoma Growers Win $7.3M Verdict Against Tyson










